New England
|
Share:

 

Dr. Ryan Brady contemplated the knowledge of God’s transcendence on a recent Wednesday evening, as students at 91ºÚÁÏ, New England, carefully listened to his Tutor Talk.

Dr. Brady opened his talk by asking whether man’s natural reason is sufficient to arrive at the truth of God’s transcendence, or if revelation is necessary to know this truth. He introduced two opposing views, quoting St. Thomas to support the idea that God’s transcendence is knowable through reason alone, and Msgr. Robert Sokolowski, who proposed the view that revelation is necessary to know this aspect of God. “This contention, then, is that the distinction between the world and God has not, in fact, been achieved by reason alone, though it can be grasped by reason once it is revealed.�

Dr. Brady then dove into the two opposing views, providing objections to Fr. Sokolowski’s argument as he proved that God’s transcendence is knowable through reason alone. His objections followed the pre-Christian philosophers, showing, through them, that the notion of God being outside the world was held before Christianity. 

He first analyzed the pre-Socratic philosophers and Plato, demonstrating how each thinker, working without the benefit of divine revelation, reasoned his way to God’s transcendence. Regarding Plato, for example, Dr. Brady highlighted, “In the Timaeus, Plato’s god seemed to make the world freely out of his own desire that there be things to share in his own eternal nature. … It seems unlikely that his god could somehow depend on his freely willed creation.â€� 

Moving to Aristotle, Dr. Brady emphasized that the philosopher also reasoned to the transcendence of God: “Clearly, therefore, the first principle of motion, the prime mover, is unmixed with the world and is unable to be existentially dependent upon it.�

Having shown that there were philosophers who reasoned to the transcendence of God without divine revelation, Dr. Brady concluded, contrary to Fr. Sokolowski, that “there is, therefore, a truly positive role to natural reason, and we have come to see how the philosophers we investigated used it to understand God in a way that is very compatible with revelation.â€� 

 

Receive lectures and talks via podcast!